What to Pay First When Cash Runs Short This Month
It is Thursday afternoon. The business account holds $4,180. Sitting in front of you are bills totalling $11,600, payroll clears tomorrow morning, and the client who owes you $9,400 has gone quiet since the second reminder.

It is Thursday afternoon. The business account holds $4,180. Sitting in front of you are bills totalling $11,600, payroll clears tomorrow morning, and the client who owes you $9,400 has gone quiet since the second reminder. Something is not getting paid, and you have about eighteen hours to decide what.
Most owners in that position start with the invoice that has the angriest email attached to it. I understand the instinct, and it is almost always the wrong sort. The question is not who is most upset. The question is which unpaid bill does the most damage per dollar, because the answers differ by a factor of twenty and some of them follow you personally long after the business recovers.
Sort by consequence, not by volume
Two popular pieces of advice circulate in small business groups whenever money gets tight. The first is to clear the smallest bills so the list gets shorter. The second is to protect your credit score above everything else. Both are reasonable in normal months and both can hurt you in a crunch.
Clearing small bills feels productive because five items disappear from a spreadsheet. It also spends $900 on vendors who would have waited three weeks without comment, money you then do not have for the payroll tax deposit that carries a penalty and personal exposure. The list got shorter and the risk went up.
The credit score argument is closer to correct but still misapplied. A credit card payment made nine days late typically costs a late fee of around $35 plus a few days of interest, and most issuers do not report a late payment to the bureaus until it is 30 days past due. That makes a card the cheapest thing on your list to delay briefly, which is the opposite of how most owners rank it. What you cannot delay is anything the tax authority classifies as money you were holding on someone else's behalf.
So the sorting rule I give every client is this: rank each bill by what happens on day 10, day 30 and day 90 of non payment, then pay in order of severity. Write it down once, during a calm week, and you will not have to think clearly at 4pm on a Thursday.
The order that holds up under pressure
This is the ladder I use, from first dollar out to last.
- Payroll tax deposits and sales tax. This is not your money. In the United States, unpaid payroll withholding exposes owners and responsible staff to the trust fund recovery penalty, which is personal liability for the full withheld amount even if the business later closes. Sales tax works the same way in most states. Nothing else on this list carries that consequence.
- Net wages to staff. Late payroll causes people to leave, and in many jurisdictions it triggers statutory penalties on top of the wages owed. It also costs you goodwill you will need next month.
- Anything that stops the business operating tomorrow. The utility with a disconnection notice, the software subscription that holds your customer records, the insurance policy that lapses, the one supplier whose material you cannot substitute. For most firms this is a short list of three or four names.
- Secured loan payments. If a lender has a claim on the van or the equipment you work with, missing payments eventually removes your ability to earn. Lenders are also the most willing to restructure if you call before the due date.
- Rent. Commercial landlords usually have a late fee around 5 percent and a cure period written into the lease. Read your lease before assuming rent is untouchable, since the notice period is often 10 or 15 days.
- Trade suppliers with flexible terms. The ones who have known you for years. Call them rather than going silent.
- Credit card minimums. Expensive over time, cheap to be late by a few days.
- Owner draws and discretionary spending. Last, which is the part nobody enjoys.
The ladder shifts in two situations. If you are in a trade where one supplier controls the only material you use, that supplier moves up above rent. And if you have a loan covenant that triggers a default on a single missed payment, read the document before deciding, because a technical default can pull forward the whole balance.
What each delay actually costs
Put numbers on it and the ranking stops feeling like a judgement call. These are typical figures in the United States for a business delaying a $5,000 obligation.
| Obligation | Cost of being 10 days late | Worse outcome later |
|---|---|---|
| Payroll tax deposit | 5 percent penalty, around $250, plus interest | Rises to 10 percent, then personal liability for the withheld portion |
| Net wages | No direct fee, immediate trust damage | State wage claims, penalties, staff resignations |
| Supplier with 2/10 net 30 terms | Lost 2 percent discount, around $100 | Credit hold, prepayment required on the next order |
| Commercial rent | Late fee near 5 percent, around $250 | Default notice after the cure period in the lease |
| Credit card minimum | Late fee near $35 plus interest | Bureau reporting at 30 days, penalty APR on the balance |
| Equipment loan | Late fee, often 5 percent of the instalment | Repossession of the asset you work with |
The supplier line is the one that surprises people. Skipping a 2 percent early payment discount on net 30 terms to hold cash for twenty extra days works out to roughly 36 percent on an annual basis, which is dearer than almost any line of credit. In a genuine crunch you take that cost anyway, because the alternative is a payroll penalty. Knowing the price keeps it from becoming a habit once cash recovers.
Three calls to make before the money runs out
Everything above assumes the cash total is fixed. It usually is not, and the difference comes from calls made on Thursday rather than apologies sent on Monday.
Call the client who owes the most and ask for a part payment with a date, not for the full amount. The request that gets paid is specific: half of the invoice by Friday, the rest on the fifteenth. A vague request to settle the account as soon as possible gets filed. We laid out the wording for this in the piece on how to chase late invoices without losing the client.
Call your two largest suppliers and propose a date before they chase you. In my experience roughly two thirds of suppliers accept a two or three week extension when the owner calls first and names a date, and the ones who refuse tell you something useful about the relationship. Silence is what converts a late payment into a credit hold.
Call the bank about the facility you already have rather than applying for something new. Drawing $6,000 on an existing line at 14 percent costs about $23 in interest for ten days. That is cheaper than a payroll tax penalty by an order of magnitude, and it buys the time to collect the receivable properly.
Fixing the month after this one
A crunch that arrives as a surprise on Thursday was visible three weeks earlier. The pattern I see in nearly every shortfall is a single large receivable landing in the same week as payroll and a quarterly tax deposit, with no view of the collision until it happens.
Two habits remove most of these. Keep tax money out of the operating account, moving the withheld payroll tax into a separate account on the day you run payroll, so it cannot be spent on a supplier invoice by accident. And keep a rolling view of the next thirteen weeks, with each known large outflow on the week it lands, which is covered step by step in the guide to building a 13 week cash flow forecast.
Write your own version of the ladder today and keep it with your bookkeeping notes. The owners who come out of a shortfall without a tax notice are rarely the ones with more cash. They are the ones who already decided the order before the pressure arrived. More on timing and reserves sits in the cashflow section.
Frequently asked questions
What bill should a small business pay first in a cash shortfall?
Payroll taxes and sales tax, because that money was collected on behalf of someone else and carries personal liability. Net wages come next, then anything that stops you operating within days.
Is it better to pay the smallest bills or the largest?
Neither. Pay by consequence. A small payroll tax deposit outranks a large supplier invoice from a vendor who has waited patiently before.
Will paying a credit card late ruin my credit?
A payment a few days late usually means a fee and interest. Most issuers report to credit bureaus only once an account reaches 30 days past due, so the damage comes from drifting rather than from one short delay.
Should I tell suppliers I am short on cash?
Tell them you are paying on a specific later date and name it. Most suppliers accept a short extension when asked before the due date, and they stop extending credit to businesses that simply go quiet.
More in Cash Flow
Cash Flow
Payment Processor Payout Times and Your Cash Flow
A bakery client of mine took $6,240 in card sales over a Friday and Saturday, which was a good weekend, and then bounced a...
Cash Flow
How to Calculate the Cash Conversion Cycle for Your Business
Your sales are up 30 percent on last year, and yet the bank balance keeps sinking every time you restock.
Cash Flow
How to Ask for a Client Deposit Before Work Starts
You start a six week project, buy the materials, put in 80 hours, and then wait 45 days after the final invoice to see a cent.